[x]

deviantART

 

Criticism From The Most Unexpected Of Places

Sat Aug 12, 2006, 11:55 PM
About a year ago, Richard and I were fortunate enough to be interviewed for Excite! Japan. This net-based article was posted on the Japanese site, and never fully translated to English. The author was a very sweet girl by the name of Tomoko, who really did make me feel very good about our job, and she seemed to enjoy our comic.

Tonight I decided to poke around Google under my pen name. Oh come on, we all do it sometimes. It’s fascinating to see what kind of crap your name pulls up. Try it sometime. Anyway, I saw some Japanese site come up with this particular web article listed. Well not speaking much Japanese other than what I affectionately call “otaku speak” (or in other words, I can screech things in an annoyingly high voice that would normally only be heard in a hentai or something lame like that), curiosity got the better of me and I decided to go one step further than squinting at the kanji on my screen.

Enter Alta Vista’s Bablefish.

I was both amused and somewhat surprised to see that most of the comments were VERY negative. They were somewhat accusatory and made me seem like a silly American who is just capitalizing on the popularity of the Anime and Manga style. One of the comments even went so far as to say that drawing ‘large eyes and big boobs’ doesn’t make it Anime.

Now, I know for a fact that Bablefish isn't the most detailed of translators. But you can get the tone of something down. And believe me, the tone sucked.

I’m sort of on a line on this one. I am both offended, and yet I can’t argue. It sort of hurts my feelings. Granted, I’m American. I know my audience is mostly here in the states, though we have readers in Australia, Britain, Brazil, and numerous other countries. And I'm grateful for that! Hell I'm grateful anyone gives a damn to read at all. But remember, Otaku –no- Yen is not meant for really anyone but English speaking Anime and Manga fans who have specifically grown up in the U.S.A. That’s what I know, so that’s what we do. We get a fairly large readership from Japan, but now I’m wondering if we were really fairly represented in this article. Anyway, if you are from Japan, and you read the comic, I’d love to hear some commentary. You can always email me at guardiansun@gmail.com.

I just want everyone to remember something. I don’t do this art style because it is popular, or to make a buck. I’ve been doing this for nearly 6 years, because I love the style of it, and our comic isn’t trying to masquerade as anything but American. So if for some god forsaken reason we offended someone along the way, please don’t lynch me. I’m kind of fond of living. =P

Devious Comments

love 1 1 joy 0 0 wow 0 0 mad 0 0 sad 0 0 fear 0 0 neutral 1 1

I've done that too. But I'm always getting someone whos ratting on a pic of mine here and there. Especially my fanarts of fanart. Though if I were in your place I probably would've been all like "Hey at least their reading it. XD" All Naive that I am. X3

Though somehow I see you putting this event in ONY... XD And putting your own halarious twist on it... lol XD One way I cope with criticts is by making something bad, funny X3 lol XD I guess I'm an overly optimistic freak... lol XD Ah well A lot of my buds love my "heart that 6 sizes too big" personallity... so ya... lol XD

--
Tina: Now that's not an American saying. "Welcome to America! -I'd rather not drive with my pants off..."

Mom chit-chatting with me: You know I'm glad that things are a little clearer now, like dirty river water... rather than mud.
Well, y'never know. Did you maybe look at other articles from the same source? one possibility is that there are sources out there that criticizes pretty much everything in a given category and such, or even just plain everything... Another thing I might try is look/ask around (which I realize you're already doing) to see wether that sort of reception is very universal... I highly doubt it is. Though I guess I could be wrong... (Is generally pessimistic...)

--
They called me mad...
They said my ideas were improbable and impractical...
They were right, but that's irrelevant.

Earth? Heaven? Hell? It's all the same to me now...
Oh I doubt it's universal. I've gotten a few emails from japan stating they enjoy the comic and are humored to no end over my obsession with 'pretty boys'. It just struck me as sort of surprising. I didn't loose sleep or anything, but sometimes it's worth asking questions, ya know?
Ha! I love doing that~ it's amazing what you find, sometimes...

You know, I never even thought of ONY as anything other than a "webcomic" - you don't seem to be trying to maqurade as a "manga" or something else, and even if you were, who cares? I hate people who think that "manga" and "anime" means that it has to be from japan and that is that. Sorry, personal little rant there.

I just see your comic as that, a comic that is hillarious to read and I'm just grateful that you do them so often!

--
"Don't cry because it's over. Smile because it happened." ~ Dr. Seuss

Why watch anime when you can be anime? Custom Cosplay Commissions [link]
I'm grateful that someone actually sees things on the same level. Granted I love hearing different perspectives on all of this. It just helps to know i'm not entirely assinine in my assumptions and opinions. =)
Hey I know what you mean by that everyone thinks that if you are doing this, you are just trying to ride the cash flow. I personally love the style and love the culture of Japan. I love to immerse myself in that and it shows in my art. Don't let them get you down, assholes always run around throwing thier OPs everywhere. Stand for what you believe in hun *smiles* I believe in you ^_^

--
I see you lying next to me

With words I thought I'd never speak

Awake and unafraid

Asleep or dead?
unfortunately that's the reaction your doomed to get from thier view point....cause there are people in america runining the art form by milking its popularity for the buck
Oh of course. It's sacred to them. *sigh* I just wish the views weren't such. I gave up on the idea of being some big wig in Japan ages ago. I'm not even upset by that. I just hope that as the generations pass, the views slowly change a bit.
I have to agree that there has been a commercialization of manga and anime here in the US. 10+ years ago you couldn't have sold enough of the stuff to pay for the cost of the paper it's printed on. Now, as its popularity has grown, so has the marketability of the work, so as one would expect, people are doing just that.

However, what I think many people forget in their rush to enforce a purist viewpoint is that manga and anime are commercial arts in Japan as well. ^.~

Manga's relationship with Japanese readers is much the same as comics and cartoons are with Americans, if not more so. Everyone from children to the elderly read manga, and you can buy toys, games, t-shirts, lunch boxes, and even shot glasses silkscreened with various characters of popular anime shows in nearly every department store, convenience store, and many vending machines all throughout Japan.

If anything, here in the United States this effect is somewhat subdued as our culture has a mild disdain for comic books and cartoons; relegating it to children and the "geek" subculture as caricatured in many television shows, moves, and radio programs. To find someone reading the latest issue of Superman on a bus is a rare sight, but to see a grown man in Japan reading a manga on the train to work is not even remotely surprising.

All in all I think it's more likely related to that that many people probably dislike the idea that a cultural tradition is being enjoyed by a group of people who don't understand most of the cultural context that underlies and motivates anime and manga, even though the medium is still being enjoyed from a different cultural perspective.

--
Insert witty line here with shameless link to gallery and desperate plea to be noticed amongst the sea of thousands of users.

Site Map